Do career women make bad mothers?

Do career women make bad mothers?

Over the Christmas break, I had the displeasure of being dragged to a nightclub. Not a particularly good nightclub either, but one of those where they rob you of your five pounds before you can even place your foot onto the sticky, sweat-infested carpet, a nightclub in which you immediately regret not being in your warm, cosy bed at 2am as you attempt to dance to Cheryl Cole’s ‘Fight For This Love’. Trust me; I tried it and you cannot physically dance to this track. It is soulless.

On this particular evening, my resentment for nightclubs was fuelled not only by the incidents listed above, but also by an advert in the toilets. “Career Women Make Bad Mothers” blazed across the toilet cubicle door in bright purple capitals. What was this campaign advertising exactly? And how the fuck were they getting away with it?

After some research into the unidentified advert, I found that this horrendous campaign was instigated by Beta agency to highlight the effectiveness of ‘outdoor advertising’. Confused? You should be.

I, like many other intelligent men and women in the UK, was outraged by the sexism of the statement in a time when women’s rights are still under scrutiny. At a time when politicians are insinuating that single parents and working mothers are contributing to a ‘Broken Britain’ of gun crimes, benefit fraud and general disarray. One woman posted a poignant complaint on the Mumsnet website in which she wrote: “The one on the side of the building today felt like a kick in the stomach.” She is right. It does.

Sharon Johnson, the strategic head of Beta, said that the posters were meant to spark debate and were not representative of the opinions of the agency. Thankfully, the posters have been taken down from public view, replaced by another ‘debate sparking’ statement: “1966. It won’t happen this year.”

One must ask the question: do Beta actually think that scepticism surrounding England’s chances in the next World Cup compares to the sexual discrimination in the slogan “Career Women Make Bad Mothers”? In my eyes, the two cannot compare.

If England are unsuccessful again this year, a few wealthy footballers may have a couple of thousand pounds cut from their hefty pay packets and some football hooligan may punch another football fan in the face as a result of Owen missing an open net, but I wouldn’t exactly call this calamity. Compare this to a century of women’s rights campaigning being overturned, and the dissemination of patriarchal ideology across the UK.

What worries me more is the location where I first saw the advert, plastered on the back of a female toilet door in a nightclub in a largely working-class area. For starters, this location means that the viewer will be female and isolated when confronting the advert. In addition to being intoxicated by alcohol, she’d most likely be uneducated in gender debates and women’s rights.

In this location, there is no room for the debate that Beta claimed to covet. When you are inebriated and isolated in a toilet cubicle, the ideology of the advert is less likely to be questioned and more likely to be consciously, or in most cases unconsciously, absorbed.

My fear is that pointless advertisements like this can have a profoundly negative effect on working-class women, who already have low aspirations and doubts about their abilities, and that these kinds of ideas will inhibit them from making ambitious choices for their future.

This shameless product of patriarchal ideology does feel like “a kick in the stomach” after women have died in trying to make tomorrow a world of gender equality. It seems that women have come so far, but yet have so far to go, especially when blatantly chauvinist campaigns like this raise their ugly heads.


1 Comment »

  1. E Said:

    Firstly, don’t get me started on Cheryl Cole’s solo music.

    In terms of this being an issue I would say that in certain scenarios it may have an adverse effect. If there’s an equal balance between the father and mother in terms of hours worked and involvement in the child’s upbringing then the father would have the same risk as being a bad parent as the mother. However, in British society today woman are on the whole (not without exception) tend to have a larger role in the raising of children. From personal experience my mother often worked 60-70 hour weeks and in my opinion couldn’t have done a better job in both work and in raising me, so in my mind its not a question of whether a woman can have both to that extent. As I have said though I can see scenarios where this would not be possible.
    I realise this was not the main point you were addressing in your article but wished to discuss it.

    As far as from an advertising perspective I would have to say that it achieved a reaction, which was the aim of the campaign. In that sense it was successful.
    However, as it is doubtful that a similar poster was in the men’s toilet I can see this as being unequal. I accept that this could make women who are not confident in themselves question whether a highly active career will suit them, and as a result may point them away from trying to have both.

{ RSS feed for comments on this post} · { TrackBack URI }

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: